NewBeauty: Catrice HD High Cover Concealer
Celebrity Makeup Artist Melissa Hurkman breaks down self-setting concealer, how it works and why it can create a seamless, skin-like finish.
What is self-setting concealer?
A self-setting concealer is basically a concealer that's formulated to set down on its own after application, so you don't necessarily need to go over it with a separate setting powder. It usually starts out creamy and blendable, then dries down to more of a soft, set finish.
Does it really work? If so, how?
Yes, it can work really well. The formula is designed with ingredients that help it lose some of that initial slip as it sits on the skin, so once you blend it out and give it a moment, it becomes more transfer-resistant and stays in place better. I still think application matters a lot—you want to use thin layers and avoid applying more product than you actually need.
How is this different from a traditional concealer and setting powder routine?
With a traditional concealer, you're usually using powder afterward to take away excess moisture, lock everything into place, and help prevent creasing. A self-setting concealer is trying to give you both steps in one formula. The biggest difference for me is the finish. Skipping powder can keep the under-eye looking fresher and more skin-like, especially if you're someone who tends to look dry or heavy once powder is added.
What skin types, ages, or skin concerns do you recommend self-setting concealer for?
I especially like the idea for normal to dry skin, dehydrated under-eyes, or anyone who feels like traditional concealer plus powder starts to look heavy. It can also be great for someone who wants a really natural, undetectable finish. That said, if you're extremely oily or your concealer tends to move throughout the day, you may still benefit from a very small amount of powder in specific areas.
How is it when it comes to creasing, especially in fine lines or textured under-eye areas?
It can actually be really beautiful in fine lines because you're eliminating that extra layer of powder, which is often what can exaggerate texture. But no concealer is completely crease-proof. The biggest thing is using a very thin amount, blending it well, and letting it settle for a minute. If I notice any product collecting in a line, I'll usually tap that out before it fully sets.
Would you recommend it for mature skin, and does it behave differently there than on younger skin?
Yes, I think mature skin can really benefit from a good self-setting concealer because less product is usually more flattering around the eye. Powder can sometimes make mature under-eyes look drier or emphasize texture, so being able to skip that step can keep everything looking softer and more hydrated. The key is finding a self-setting formula that still has flexibility and doesn't dry down too matte. On younger or smoother skin, you can usually get away with a wider range of finishes, whereas on mature skin I would specifically look for something that stays creamy and skin-like even after it sets.
Do you have any you recommend?
I really love the new Catrice HD High Cover Concealer—it has been my go-to, not only for myself, but for my clients. It gives the perfect blur to the skin and covers seamlessly while setting itself enough that you don't need to use powder over top. I also love Natasha Denona concealer, which is also a great self-setting concealer.